Sunday, March 5th, 2006

Ajax Libraries: How Portable?

Category: Browsers, Library

Leland Scott has done some serious research into portability of many Ajax libraries and frameworks out there. He built the list from several sources:

He came up with a grading system – “A” for DOM-compliant browsers that support the four majors (IE, FF, Safari, Opera) – down to “E” for IE-only. Of all the products reviewed, here are the ones that picked up an “A” rating:

Dojo Toolkit
Behaviour
Moo.fx
DHTML Kitchen
Prototype
DynAPI 3.0
Rico
How To Create
Sardalya
Open Cube
Script.aculo.us
Todd Ditchendorf’s DHTML Gallery
Tacos
Walter Zorn
TurboWidgets
X Library
TwinHelix
Wicket
Yahoo! User Interface Library

Look at Leland’s article for the full report.

He also explains the background for this study:

2005 started with the amazing and improbable reentrance of Javascript as a respectable tool for web application development. At its side was a new kid called Ajax, which was a fancy name for a greatly enhanced version of the layer tag’s src attribute from 1997. We have Google to thank for recognizing that the time was ripe, once again, to begin expanding the web application’s potential. With Google Maps and gMail, Google had the market power to showcase some truly amazing and Different apps that got a lot of geeks thinking “outside the box” again after many years.

And that’s when it hit me, some time last fall: The vision of a rich and OS-agnostic web was still possible, after all.

An Apple and Safari user, his pleasure gradually turned to disappointment as he discovered many libraries weren’t supporting the full suite of browsers, inspring the study.

I dove in and began checking out the large array of new toolkits that were available for Ajax and DHTML. It wasn’t long before I started worrying again. It turns out that some of these libraries actually supported only IE, or only IE and Firefox, or (in one case) only Safari. Most alarming was the large percentage of Ajax/DHTML libraries that failed to include Safari.

Posted by Michael Mahemoff at 3:06 pm
14 Comments

++++-
4.2 rating from 39 votes

14 Comments »

Comments feed TrackBack URI

Finally, a thorough review of the Libraries!

I’ve been needing somthing like this for a while. thanks!

Comment by ian — March 5, 2006

A very interesting entry. I guess things would have looked a little changed if IE compatibility would be measured against IE 5.5 and higher. I don’t have any rankings for the browser market shares, but I am almost sure that IE 5.5 has more market share than Opera. I would really like to see those ratings with this new hypothesis.

cheers,

./alex

.w( the_mindstorm )p.

Comment by Alex Popescu — March 5, 2006

A side comment: while writting the comment, I see a really annoying effect: the Google ads keep flickerin on the left-side. For each keypressed. I think this is a bug ;-). And as for a bug report: FF 1.0.7 on Win XP SP2.

BR,

./alex

.w( the_mindstorm )p.

Comment by Alex Popescu — March 5, 2006

Hi friends,
I want to present to you some Vietnamese websites:
[URL=http://www.onboom.com]Vietnam’s Pro Site Submission-Increase web ranking for Google, Yahoo, MSN[/URL] – The Internet Promotion Group. OnBoom can support enterprises that get their sites to be ranking on Top Google, Yahoo!, MSN.
[URL=http://www.saovangdatviet.com.vn]Thuong Hieu Viet-Quang cao truc tuyen-Quang ba san pham[/URL] – Sao vang dat Viet is the best online promotion company in Vietnam. We support vietnamese enterprises get their brands, products, services on my site to advert. We want our customers be succeed.
[URL=http://www.phulamhuunghi.com]Cassava, Coir and Paper raw materials wood[/URL] – Sell cassava slice, cassava starchy, coir in bale, paper raw materials wood to Chinese market.
[URL=http://www.addvn.com]Online Promotion Solutions-Giai Phap quang cao truc tuyen[/URL] – Provides cheap but effective online marketing solutions in Vietnam.
[URL=http://www.truongquoctemy.edu.vn]Vietnam’s English Education – Children Education – Toefl, Toeic training[/URL] – The best education for English training in Vietnam.
[URL=http://www.vhsvietnam.com]GPS Equipments (GPS Garmin, GPS Magellan, GPS Promak2)-Nha cung cap thiet bi GPS[/URL] – The best Vietnam’s GPS machines provider website. It provides alot of equipments for: Forest equipment, environment, measuring, fire.
[URL=http://www.banhangtructiep.com]Ban hang truc tiep, kinh doanh truc tuyen, dung cu the duc the thao, phu gia xang dau[/URL], phu gia nhien lieu, laptop gia re, may tinh xach tay, noi that dai loan, mua hang gia goc

Comment by onboom — March 6, 2006

You could build your own powerful reusable GUI classes to build graphics intensive application in the future. The following web page teaches you how you could build powerful reusable Ajax components:

http://cbsdf.com/misc_docs/gui-api-brief.htm

I just thought that some of you fellow geeks like to play with new toys. The web site has nothing to sell now except to introduce new and innovative technologies.

Comment by John Davis — March 6, 2006

wat ik lees en luister: AJAX / Webdevelopment

Doordat ik een ipod gekocht heb ben ik meer gaan kijken naar podcasting.
Ik heb ’subscriptions’ genomen op diverse webdev gerelateerde podcasts via iTunes, waaronder de podcast van ajaxian.com.
Een bestwel interessante podcast.
Deze podcast…

Trackback by Jeroen van Wissen — March 6, 2006

Very interesting post.
It helps choosing the right framework for developing webbased applications. As a mac / safari user, it points me to compatible libraries.

Comment by Jeroen van Wissen — March 6, 2006

recommend a website of china
http://www.id91.com

Comment by wowo — March 6, 2006

Here’s a thought. Don’t use crappy Safari. Or… Safari makers finally make a good browser? Nahhh, probably option A is the best bet (most feasible).

Comment by Ryan Gahl — March 6, 2006

Ok, I must agree Ryan. But with Safari beeing the default browser on mac, and IE beeing the default on windows platforms. Useable webapplications should work and render right on them.

Comment by Jeroen van Wissen — March 6, 2006

Sorry, just being cynical. Gosh darn browser makers. Why is that we (the developer community at large) are STILL suffering from their inability (or unwillingness?) to get things right? This shouldn’t even be an article. Gosh darn browser makers.

Comment by Ryan Gahl — March 6, 2006

Ajax has gotten me noticed

After being here for well over 4 years I have finaly been noticed. I had done some Ajax research and I wanted it in a place that I could get to it where ever I was. So I placed it up on my website here. To my amazement it has been noticed.
It all start…

Trackback by Savage Vines — March 7, 2006

Listado de librerías Ajax/DHTML. Portabilidad y compatibilidad con los navegadores

Tras el completo listado de manuales y tutoriales sobre Ajax, me dispongo ahora a continuar la cadena refiriéndome a este artículo de Leland Scott, el cual ofrece una interesantísima lista de librerías y entornos para la programación con Ajax y J…

Trackback by DeltaBlog — March 31, 2006

Good site I found … Plan on coming back later.

Comment by shadows — January 19, 2007

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.