Monday, September 24th, 2007

IE Feedback: Closed for Business

Category: IE

Say no more?

IE Feedback

Posted by Dion Almaer at 12:43 am
22 Comments

++---
2.9 rating from 26 votes

22 Comments »

Comments feed TrackBack URI

hahah

Comment by Matthew — September 24, 2007

It’s instructive to read one of the stories behind this: http://www.arcanology.com/2007/09/19/ie-and-the-demise-of-borgzilla/

Fascinating, and deeply distressing.

Comment by Alex Russell — September 24, 2007

What is to stop someone setting up a bugzilla installation for people to contribute to.

Watching the total bugs grow daily would shame the hell outta them.

Comment by pd — September 24, 2007

A bugzilla installation for IE bugs that is.

Even though contributors might never see responses, it would be fun to contribute in order to shame the evil MS. In particular I’d like to shame them into fixing IE6 since that craptacular browser still accounts for 60% of the audience on one site I’m involved with.

Comment by pd — September 24, 2007

Ugh that is so typical. Why am I not surprised.

Comment by Jim Jeffers — September 24, 2007

If you click on the link it does take you to the new functioning support page. Definitely a rookie mistake not to forward automatically or at least make the message easier to understand.

Comment by sc — September 24, 2007

Isn’t the whole “MS is evil” thing a bit old? I can see the humour in a page like that, but in the end they still provide support, just at a different page. I would’ve hoped that a blog like Ajaxian would bypass this kind of stuff.

Comment by Ron — September 24, 2007

To sc and Ron,

There’s a difference between feedback and support.

Comment by Trevor — September 24, 2007

They just forsing users to used other communication channel. If you have any feedback from that browser meaning that you using it.

Comment by Nik Chankov — September 24, 2007

Is this news? It’s been closed for a year….

Comment by HÃ¥vard Pedersen — September 24, 2007

Please put stuff (its not worth to say news) like that on other blogs but not on ajaxian….the whole “MS is evil” thing is infantile! I’am not the biggest MS fan but c’mooon!!

Comment by math — September 24, 2007

I think only one commenter has mentioned MS being evil. My personal feeling is that they are no more or less evil than any other corporate entity.

However, I think a lot of the issues that I (and others) have with MS is frustration that one of the most profitable software companies in the world can’t seem to muster an ounce of competence when it comes to designing a browser that the rest of the world can use as a webapp platform.

Have they really done anything worthwhile in web browsers since 5.5? They’ve even abandoned their own browser for their email client. If it’s not good enough for them to use, what makes them think that it’s ready for consumers?

One day the wave of winning salvo 1 of the browser wars will crest. Then, perhaps, a better market leader will emerge.

Or at least one that gives a hoot about standards and the web developer community.

Even though no one’s asking me, I’d say MS is leveraging it’s status in the browser community to put the brakes on RIAs — at least until it has a chance to catch up (or bury) that market. I see no other excuse for how horrible MS’ near-infinite development resources have performed with IE 6 *and* 7. And releasing a competent browser really would serve to help out competitors like Google.

Comment by Sam — September 24, 2007

Hating IE will never get old or infantile. Accept it. Love it. Embrace it.

Comment by The Hater — September 24, 2007

Microsoft isn’t evil.

Quoting Hanlon’s razor: “Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity.”

Somewhere in the IE food chain there is most likely a manager that is stubborn, ignorant, paralyzed by indecision or all three who is responsible for the current Cone of Silence over the future of the browser.

Comment by Cal Jacobson — September 24, 2007

Funny how you just link to a website that has been the same for over a year and don’t even link to the article where these “news” originated (see Alex Russell’s comment). Come on, grow up. Time to start reading/investigating more and bashing Microsoft with non-news less.

Comment by Danie Luz — September 24, 2007

MS is hurting internet =/

Comment by mefisto — September 24, 2007

Why don’t you just write your own OS and web browser ?

Comment by Kevin — September 24, 2007

Funny as it is poking fun at MS, putting up a bugzilla for IE would be a complete waste of time.

Firstly, for any bugtracking to have any value, there would have to be someone actively maintaining the list of bugs, merging duplicates, removing non-bugs, asking for clarification on bugs, etc.

Secondly, it would also have to be used by the parties involved in the product, whose bugs are being tracked.

Getting a community effort to shame MS would be really, really stupid. Shaming is not constructive, and would just make the community look bad. Offering constructive advice, as has been done for years now, will get us far better results.

And yes, that page has been like that for a year now, just another testament that either MS has something really cool up it’s collective sleeves, or that they’ve put IE to bed again, and that we’ll have to live with that crappy piece of software for many years to come.

Comment by Morgan Roderick — September 25, 2007

MS is not evil in the same sense that a hungry cannibal eating another human is not evil. It’s just pure hunger driving the guy to eat another person. It’s not evil.

MS came to an established community called “internet” and basically attempted to subvert it, and in some ways, succeeded in subverting it, for their own interests. It’s not evil. It is simply self-interest that is in conflict with just about anyone participating in the community.

When someone’s self-interest of one is conflicting with self-interests of too many other people we conventionally call it “evil”. But it’s not really evil. Point well taken. But even if it’s not evil, I will respond to it in the same manner as I would toward a hungry cannibal staring at me with a fork. It wants something I don’t want to surrender. There is a conflict.

I like standards and I like open cooperation in the community. I am not ready to surrender those values.

Comment by Leo Lipelis — September 25, 2007

IE is a terrible, terrible application and the creators of it, and those who don’t reveal the future plans for it deserve all the hating they get imo.

Everybody hates IE, and 98% of people hate MS. This is a well known fact. No need to question that.

Comment by Gavin — September 25, 2007

This also happen with Google, I was unable to report a bug of iGoogle.

However the bug still get fixed, in a month later.

Comment by chenggn — September 26, 2007

Wimps :)

Comment by Steven — October 26, 2007

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.